16
The Unholy Consult / Re: If Cish can see Souls via Third Sight, why couldn't they see skin spies...
« on: May 12, 2021, 06:20:51 am »Also, isn't it weird that despite the Dunyain reflecting a proper proportion of the God they are spiritually weak?
I don't follow what "proportion of the God" is really supposed to mean. I just read that as a soul being the "portion" of the God that is tied to a given individual. Dunyain don't lack souls, they lack the manner of Spirit (read: Geist, as Mind) that reflects into itself in a manner we could notionally call "spirituality."
Their "religion" is rather the Logos, which chains them to a differential conception of self-consciousness and so a different sort of expression of mind (and the role it should play). One that leaves them far "superior" in conscious ability but weaker to the unconscious forces that are still at play. They are still fully "souled," still self-conscious, still portions of the God, where Tekne creations are not at all. Dunyain are fully continuous/contiguous with "natural" reality, where Tekne things are not.
Do you agree with Madness that perhaps Big Moe just let Kellhus yammer on about discrepancies in voices while in truth the Cish easily rooted out the skin-spies?
I think in line with what you are saying here is that what the Cish see has, to them, always correlated with souls. They perhaps see souls as entities with passions, intellect, etc. And before they never had reason to doubt this correlation.
Perhaps it's also the case that because they felt they could still see "souls" in the skin-spies they insisted that these were not biological machinery but magical artifacts made by the Scarlet Spires?