Ha. Thats an entertaining idea. We could make a post that had some of the big questions that are commonly asked but seldom have an answer, and then have any who are strongly opinionated and willing to dig up reasons for their madness write up a paragraph or a page on their view of the answer.

I think you hit the heart of the issue. The problem is that most questions that anyone would like to have answered are more complex than they know, and few agree on any theory as a whole.

Ah Mimara's words. There is more there.

haha don't worry about it. I like answering questions so if keep asking if you need too.

Oh ok well I guess I missed that. I got tripped up on your description of Chorae and didnt answer any of your questions.

Is the JE fallible?
There is no direct or explicit evidence that TJE has 'judged' something incorrectly. Everything that Mim has seen seems to be more or less plausible.

Unable to define all things Inchoroi?
I don't think Mim has seen anything Inchoroi.

Making reality?
This is an interesting question that really delves into the metaphysics of Earwa. As far as we have been told, the Eye just sees things as they 'truely' are. But I have no idea if that is true. Its possible that it sees only what Mim wants to see, or that its some special manipulated artifact that Kellhus controls, etc etc. Insert conspiracy theory here.

All the difference for what?

Its just a forbidden branch of sorcery. So was the Wathi doll that Akka has/had, or the Diamos that dear Iyokos wields/wielded.

I don't think that some schoolman giving aliens some of their technology is particularly important.

Assuming of course that there are different levels of topoi... Maybe it goes out like distance rather than magnatude. By that I mean, once something has achieved 'topoi' it is some kind of bridge to the outside. The bridge can get bigger, but a bridge doesn't become more-bridge-like. So maybe the depth of atrocity just makes the area larger. So because of all the suffereing, most or all of Agongorea is Golgotterath's topoi.

Well from my personal (and biased) experience, I'd say  its totally worth it. Though I was a participant in making the posts in some cases, its still a lot of fun to read the thoughts of everyone around, especially our  conflicting ones. Definitely comment on old threads as you see fit. Oh, and not all the posts have anything to do with TSA so you might not need to read them all.

Does anyone know how many languages TSA have been published in?

I thought it would be entertaining to try and collect first edition copies of the books in other languages. Though since I can only speak or read english, it might be a challenge. But thats the fun part right? If it was easy, what would be the point?

That way, whenever Bakker shows up somewhere where I can go see him again, I'll have some interesting books to have him sign. Though AE is still pretty new and finding first editions should be easy, it should be more difficult to find PoN (or at least thats the hope).

Also, is TPB the only place where he mentions that he might show up somewhere or is there someplace else that would be good to look?