Those are some of the exact questions, Capt. Croaker opened the thread with.
If Mimara watches from the most "objective" God's Eye possible, then:
I suspect Kellhus would be Damned - unless he's figured out the Titirga/Cishaurim spectrum and has established himself. I suspect all sorcerers/swayali would still be Damned, but probably not Cishaurim.
But Mimara might be preceded by any of the Gods, really. She holds to Kiunnat and, specifically, Yatwerian beliefs as does Esmenet. It might also be the Solitary God's Eye, rather than the God of Gods.
On that note, if there were no instances of the Judging Eye before Inri Sejenus articulated the God of Gods, then I'd be more inclined to believe it... not that it wouldn't have occurred, but it might not have been as well defined in the histories until Sejenus suggested a God of Gods.