The Second Apocalypse

Miscellaneous Chatter => Philosophy & Science => Topic started by: sciborg2 on March 13, 2020, 09:55:06 pm

Title: Why Hasn't Evolution Invented the Wheel?
Post by: sciborg2 on March 13, 2020, 09:55:06 pm
How Biological Design Differs from Human Design (https://medium.com/intuitionmachine/why-hasnt-evolution-invented-the-wheel-4de68f31ffb6)

Carlos Perez

Quote
    Dave Ackley (Well known for Boltzmann machines) proposes “Robust first computing” as a solution to this brittleness. Ackley challenges the underlying assumptions of conventional design which he calls “the iron grip of correctness”. He argues for a very different architecture that is not based on strict correctness but rather is inspired by the messy designs found in biology. Strict correctness maximizes the consequences of failure. Ackley argues for an alternative architecture that favors “strict indefinite scalability” where you have to give up on global hardware determinism. He calls this “living computation”, where best effort computation is favored over correctness. Correctness becomes more like an ‘ility’ than a requirement. His architecture flips the design goals such that systems must be as robust as possible, followed by correctness and then efficient as necessary.

What is desperately needed is technology that supports organic intelligence. Fortunately, we are seeing the primordial emergence of such technology. This technology is known as Deep Learning. Deep Learning captures the robustness of biological evolution and combines it with the creativeness of virtual design exploration."

This seems overly optimistic to me...
Title: Re: Why Hasn't Evolution Invented the Wheel?
Post by: Francis Buck on July 05, 2020, 02:46:05 am
I mean, I feel like the reason is because wheels kinda suck as a form of locomotion? When would wheels be better than multiple, articulated, terrain-adaptable limbs (which usually double as a gripping mechanism, self-defense, interacting with the environment, climbing, masturbation, etcetera). Long story short, wheels are overrated.

Also, this: https://youtu.be/ltvLo2vNls0?t=124 (https://youtu.be/ltvLo2vNls0?t=124)
Title: Re: Why Hasn't Evolution Invented the Wheel?
Post by: Wilshire on July 05, 2020, 04:40:36 pm
I mean, I feel like the reason is because wheels kinda suck as a form of locomotion? When would wheels be better than multiple, articulated, terrain-adaptable limbs (which usually double as a gripping mechanism, self-defense, interacting with the environment, climbing, masturbation, etcetera). Long story short, wheels are overrated.
I like that lol.