Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - TheCulminatingApe

Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 19
61
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 5
« on: February 03, 2019, 05:20:38 pm »
Conphas is slightly confused
Quote
Strange, this feeling.  Curiously childlike, though when he racked his soul, Ikurei Conphas could find no resembling childhood memory. It was as though he'd been bruised beneath the skin, on his heart, or even his soul.  A strange sense of fragility dogged his every look, his every word.  He no longer trusted his face... It was as though certain muscles had been removed.
"For some it a defect carried from the womb"

The Nansur troops are disarmed.  Some defect and rejoin the Holy War.  More than four in five remain loyal to the Lion of Kiyuth.
Quote
Conphas raised his forearm in Imperial salute, and his men raised theirs in thundering reply.  Tears clouded his eyes.  The bruise of his indignities began to fade, especially when he heard Proyas declare the terms extended by the Warrior-Prophet.
A fleet is coming from Momemn to pick up the Nansur - they don't have to cross the desert.

Conphas questions his staff.
Quote
"Tell me, what man doesn't aspire to godhead"
The consensus was, not surprisingly, absolute.  All men they said, sought to emulate the Gods, though only the most bold, the most honest, dared voice their ambitions. Of course, the fools simply mouthed what they thought he wanted to hear.  Ordinarily this would have incensed Conphas - no command could tolerate sycophants - but his uncertainty made him curiously indulgent.  After all, according to the so-called Warrior-Prophet, his was a marred soul, a deformation born of the womb.  The famed Ikurei Conphas was not quite human.
The strange thing was that he understood full well what the man had meant. His entire life, Conphas had known he was different.  He never stammered in embarrassment.  He never blushed in the presence of his betters.  He never minced his words with his worries.  All around him, men jerked this way and that, pulled by hooks that he knew only by reputation: love, guilt, duty... Though he understood how to use these words well enough, they meant nothing to him.
And the strangest thing of all that he didn't care.
Listening to his officers oblige his vanity, Conphas came to a powerful realisation: his beliefs mattered nothing, so long as they delivered what he wanted. Why make logic the rule.  Why make fact the ground?  The only consistency that mattered, the only correspondence, was that between belief and desire.  If it pleased him to think himself divine, then so he would think.  And Conphas understood that just as he possessed the remarkable ability to do anything, no matter how merciful or bloodthirsty, he also possessed the ability to believe anything.  The Warrior-Prophet could hang the ground vertical, make all things fall towards the horizon, and Conphas need only point sideways to restore the order of up and down.
Perhaps the sorceror's tales of the Consult and the Second Apocalypse were true.  Perhaps the Prince of Atrithau was some kind of saviour. Perhaps his was deformed.  It simply did not matter if he did not care.  So told himself that his life was his witness, that ages had passed without producing a soul such as his, that the Whore of Fate lusted for him and him alone...
...  He told himself that the Prince of Atrithau was the most accomplished liar he'd ever encountered - a veritable Ajokli!  He told himself that the Council had been a trap, the product of through and painstaking premeditation.
So he told himself and so he believed.  For Conphas, there was no difference between decision and revelation, manufacture and discovery.  Gods made themselves the rule.  And he was one of them.

So much of this seems to reflect Kellhus' story path.  I still think Conphas is a device to help us see what Kellhus actually is.  Also note the direct reference to Kellhus and Ajokli.

He arrives in Joktha quite happily - and then sees Cnaiur.

Cnaiur is 'forgetting something'.  He is seeing things.  Dead Utemot, horses and cattle, and Moenghus.
Quote
...The Ikurei still lives... Why don't you kill him?...
..."Because he wants me to"
The Dnyain?  You think this is a trap?
"His every word is a feint.  His every look a spear!"
Then what's his intent?
"To keep me from his father.  To deny me my hate.  To betray-"
But all you need to do is kill the Ikurei.  Kill him, and you are free to follow the Holy War.
"No!  There is something!  Something I'm..."
You're a fool

The Synthese turns up and tells him to avenge the Battle of Kiyuth.

Cnaiur tries to work out what is going on.  He has a small number of troops with him, heavily outnumbered by the Nansur.  He needs to break the will of the Nansur.  He realises that if Kellhus wants him to assassinate Conphas,the Kellhus is thinking past Shimeh and past Moenghus.

Quote
Men draped assumptions, endless assumptions, about their acts; they could scarce do otherwise, given their errant hunger for meaning.  Since the beginning, Cnaiur had conceived their journey as a hunt, as  collusion of enemies in pursuit of a greater foe.  Their quest had always seemed an arrow fired into darkness.  No matter how deep his misgivings, he had always come back to this understanding.  But now... Now it seemed like nothing other than a collar; that Moenghus and Kellhus, father and son, were but different ends of a mighty torc that he, Cnaiur urs Skiotha, had bent about the very neck of the world.  A slaver's collar.

He beats Conphas for answering him back.  He beats the other Nansur who intervene.  He salts the hidden sorceror amongst them.
Quote
Afterwards, he found himself screaming in his apartments.  He understood why, of course: if not for the Scarlet Schoolman's arrival, he would never have thought that Conphas too had a sorceror.  But the why of this understanding escaped him... It always escaped him
Was something wrong with him?
Enemies!  All about him, enemies! They even dwelt within...
Even Proyas... Could he bring himself to break his neck as well?
He sent me to murder myself
At night, Cnaiur drank - heavily - and the spears that lay hidden beneath every surface were blunted.  The terrors, rather, oozed from the cracks in the floor.  Despite the censers, the air smelled of yaksh: earth, smoke and mouldering hides.  He could hear Moenghus whisper through the dim interiors...
More lies.  More confusions.
And the bird - the fucking bird!  It seemed a knot, a yanking of all thins foul into a single form.  His chest tightened simply thinking of it.  But of course it couldn't be real.  No more than Serwe.
He told her as much, every night she came to his bed.
Something... something is wrong with me
He knew this because he could see himself as the Dunyain saw him.  He understood that Moenghus had knocked him from the tracks of his People, that he had spent thirty years kicking through the grasses searching for a spoor of his own passing.  For a way back.
Thirty accursed years!  These too he understood.  The Scylvendi were a forward people - as were all people save the Dunyain. They listened to their storytellers.  They listened to their hearts.  Like dogs, they barked at strangers.  They judged honour and shame the way they judged near and far.  In their inborn conceit, they made themselves the absolute measure.  They could not see that honour, like nearness, simply depended on where one stood.
That it was a lie.
Moenghus had lured him onto different ground.  How could his kinsmen not think him an obscenity when his voice came to them from darknesses unseen?  How could he rediscover their tracks when all grounds had trampled?  He could never be of the People, not after Moenghus.
He could never think or curse himself back to their savage innocence.  He had been a fool to try... Ignorance was ever the iron of certainty, for it was as blind to itself as sleep.  It was the absence of questions that made answers absolute - not knowledge!  To ask, this was what Moenghus had taught him.  Simply to ask...
"Why follow this track and not another?"
"Because the Voice demands it".
"Why follow this voice and not another?"
That everything could be overthrown so easily. That all custom and conviction could lay so close to the brink.  That outrage and accusation could be the only true foundations...  All of it - everything, that was man - perched and swords and screams.
Why? cried his every step.  Why? cried his every word.  Why? cried his every breath.
For some reason... There must be some reason.
But why?  Why?
The world itself had become his rebuke!  He was no longer of the Land, but he could not beat the Steppe from the cant of his limbs.  He was no longer of the People, but he could not wash his father from his blood.  He cared nothing for the ways of the Scylvendi! - nothing - yet still they howled within him, railed and railed.  He was not of the People!  Yet still his degradations choked him.  Still his longings clawed at his heart.  Wutrim!  Shame!
Absent things!  How could absent things remain!
Each time he shaved, his thumb unerringly found the swazond puckered about his throat.  He would track its ginger course.  Something... I'm forgetting something...
There were two past; Cnaiur understood that now.  There was the past that men remembered, and there was the past that determined, and rarely if ever were the same.  All men stood in thrall of the latter.
And knowing this made them insane.

Conphas has snuck out of Joktha.
Quote
If only he could forget the accursed Scylvendi!  What was it about the man?  Even now, in some small corner of his soul, a beacon fire burned at the ready in case of his return.  It was as though the barbarian had somehow stained him with the force of his presence, and now it clung, like an odour that must be scrubbed rather than rinsed away.  Never had any man possessed such an effect on him.
Perhaps this, Conphas mused, was what sin felt like for the faithful.  The intimation of something greater watching.  The sense of disapproval, at once immense and ineffable, as near as fog and yet as distant as the world's rim.  It was a though anger itself possessed eyes.
Perhaps faith was a kind of stain as well... a kind of odour.

He meets the Fanim - a meeting he has arranged long before.  Fanayal acclaims him as Emperor.

Cnaiur is speaking with the Synthese.
Quote
So what was this thing?  He had struck bargains with it.  Exchanged promises.
  What bargains and promises?

Quote
"I eclipse you, mortal!" it replied with bird-vehemence.  "I am son of a more violent race.  You cannot conceive the compass of my life!"
Cnaiur turned his profile to it, glanced at it sidelong.  "Why?  The blood that pulses through my veins is no less ancient.  Nor are the movements of my soul.  You are not so old as the Truth".
He could fairly hear the creature's sneer.
"You still do not understand them," Cnaiur continued.  "Before all, the Dunyain are intellect.  I do not know their ends, but I do know this: they make instruments of all things, and they do so with a way beyond the ken of me or even you, Demon".
"You think I underestimate them".
Cnaiur turned his back to the sea.  "It is inevitable," he said, shrugging.  "we are little more than children to them, imbeciles drawn from the womb. Think on it. Bird.  Moenghus has dwelt among the Kianene for thirty years.  I know not your power, but I do know this: he lies far beyond it."
Moenghus... Simply speaking the name cramped his heart.
"As you say, Scylvendi, you know not my power."
Cnaoir cursed and laughed.  "Would you like to know what a Dunyain would hear in your words?"
"And what might that be?"
"Posturing.  Vanity.  Weaknesses that betray you measure and offer innumerable lines of assault.  A Dunyain would grant you your declarations.  He would encourage you in your confidence.  In all things, he would dispense flattering appearances.  He would care nothing whether you thought him your lesser, your slave, so long as you remained ignorant"...
..."Ignorant?  Ignorant of what?"
Cnaiur spat.  "Your true circumstances."
"And what are my true circumstances, Scylvendi?"
"That you are  being played.  That you flounder in nets of your own making. The circumstances you struggle to master, Bird, have long ago mastered you.  Of course you thing otherwise.  Like men, power stands high among your native desires.  But you a tool, as much as any Man of the Tusk."
It crooked its head to the side.  "How then, am I to become my own instrument?"
Cnaiur snorted.  "For centuries you have manipulated events from the dark, or so you claim.  Now you assume that you must do the same, that nothing has changed.  I assure you, everything has changed.  You think yourself hidden, but you are not.  Chances are he already knows you have approached me.  Chances are he already knows your ends and your resources.
Even the ancient things, Cnaiur realised, would suffer the Holy War's fate.  The Dunyain would strip them the way the People stripped the carcasses of bison.  Flesh for sustenance.  Fat for soap and fuel.  Bone for implements.  Hide for shelter and shields.  No matter how deep they ran, the ages themselves would be consumed.  The Dunyain was something new.  Perpetually new.
Like lust or hunger.
"You must abandon you old ways, Bird.  You must strike across trackless ground.  You must surrender brute circumstance to him, because in this you cannot hope to match him.  Instead you must watch.  Wait.  You must become a student of opportunity."

Bird is not impressed and shows Cnaiur visions of its sorcerous power.  Cnaiur tells it that Kellhus is learning sorcery - and he learnt to speak Scylvendi in four days.

Cememketri is snuck in to meet Conphas.  The Saik are waiting to be 'wielded'.



62
The Almanac: PON Edition / ARC: TTT Chapter 6
« on: January 20, 2019, 06:58:05 pm »
Quote
Of course we make crutches of one another.  Why else would we crawl when we lose our lovers?
- ONTILLAS, ON THE FOLLY OF MEN

Quote
History.  Logic.  Arithmetic.  These all should be taught by slaves.
- ANONYMOUS, THE NOBLE HOUSE

63
The Almanac: PON Edition / ARC: TTT Chapter 5
« on: January 20, 2019, 06:55:34 pm »
Quote
To indulge it is to breed it.  To punish it is to feed it.  Madness knows no bridle but the knife
- SCYLVENDI PROVERB

Quote
When others speak, I hear naught but the squawking of parrots.  But when I speak, it always seems to be the first time.  Each man is the rule of the other, no matter how mad or vain.
- HATATIAN, EXHORTATIONS

64
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 4
« on: January 20, 2019, 03:58:21 pm »
Back in Momemn, Xerius looks out from the Imperial Apartments
Quote
...As his mother would say, every man was a spy in the end, an agent of contrary interests. Every face was made of fingers...

Mother comes to see him.  He tells her that Kellhus knows the Nansur are in league with Fanim.  Conphas has been turned out.

Quote
It means, Mother, that Conphas has the field.  He shrugged amiably.  "I haven't recalled him".

He is very aroused.
Quote
His fingers and palm found warm skin.  His heart became a thunderclap.  He ran his hand along her calves, which she shaved in the fashion of the Ainoni, then across her still-smooth thighs.  Could it be?  He clutched at her groin, squeezed the shaft of her erection-"
He screams, guards rush in.  The skin-spy kills many, including ultimately poor old Xerius himself.

In Shimeh, two little boys, Hertata and Sol head to the stone quays.  Maithanet is setting sail.  Sol is the worldly one.
Quote
Why should he care for Maithanet?  Men with gold rings gave no copper, unless they wanted to stick them.  Why should he care for Maithanet, who just try to stick him if he could?  Fucking priests any way.
But the tears in Hertata's eyes... Sol could see he was afraid to go alone.
Groaning, Sol stood and kicked about his rag bedding.  he tried his best to sneer at Hertata's beaming face.  He'd seen Hertata's ilk before.  Always whimpering "Mommy" in the middle of the night.  Always getting sticked for food because he was too afraid to steal.  They never survived.  None of them.  Just like his little brother...
But not Sol!  His feet were rabbit-quick...

There is a carnival atmosphere
Quote
Though he would never admit it, Sol was happy he had listened to Hertata.  Being surrounded by glad-hearted people all walking the same direction made him feel as though he belonged to something, as if through some inarticulate miracle he had found his way back inside from the filth and cold and contempt.
How long had it been since his father's murder?

Quote
...He found himself studying Hertata, who continually looked back, smiling with manic encouragement.  From where had his sudden courage come?  Everyone knew Hertata was a cringer, yet here he was, barging toward an almost certain.  Why would he risk such a thing?  For Maithanet?  As far as Sol was concerned, nothing was worth getting a beating - or even worse, getting clapped by slavers.  He would sooner be sticked.
And yet there was something in the air, something that made Sol feel uncertain in a way he had never felt uncertain before.  Something that made him feel small, not in the way of orphans or beggars or children, but in a good way.  In the way of souls.
He could remember his mother praying the night his father had dies.  Crying and praying.  Was that what drove Hertata?  Could he remember his mother praying?

Maithanet arrives.
Quote
Three lavishly garbed priests crossed the narrow slot of their view.  Then he stepped into sight. Younger.  Taller.  Paler.  A full beard.  Wearing only a simple vestment, so whit it pained the eyes to look.  A thousand pleading hands reached out toward him, to greet, to implore, to touch.  Hertata was fairly shrieking, trying to gain his majestic attention.  He merely walked, but it seemed he moved so fast, as though the ground itself pulled him forward.  For some reason, Sol raised hi hands and reached out, not to touch the luminous image before him but to jab his fingers at his friend - to point at the one soul that needed to be seen more than any other.
Perhaps it was that Sol alone, of all those lining the avenue, gestured to another.  Perhaps it was that Maithanet somehow knew.  Whatever the reason, the bright eyes flickered towards him.  Saw.
As Sol watched, Maithanet's eyes were drawn by his pointing fingers to Hertata, wailing and jumping beside him.  The Shriah of the Thousand Temples smiled.
For a breathless moment he held the boy's gaze, then the Knight's form swallowed his hallowed image.
"Yessss!"  Hertata howled, fairly weeping with disbelief.  "Yes-yes!"
Sol clutched his hand and laughed.  Still cheering, they both turned to a shadow.

A man appears.  He is slaver.  Sol flees.  Hertata's fate is not told.

The Holy War has been reduced to 40,000.  They set out from Caraskand.  2000 Galeoth remain with Saubon. 
Reinforcements have crossed the sea.
Quote
...They fell silent, however, upon entering the city, appalled by the battered faces and perpetual stares that greeted them.  The ancient customs were observed - hands were shaken, countrymen embraced - but it was all a pretence.
The original Men of the Tusk - the survivors - were now sons of a different nation.  They had spilled whatever blood they once shared with these men.  The old loyalties and traditions had become tales of a a faraway country, like Zeum, a place too distant to be confirmed.  The hooks of the old ways, the old concerns, had been set in fat that no longer existed.  Everything they had known had been tested and found wanting.  Their vanity, their envy, their hubris, all the careless bigotries of their prior lives, had been murdered with with their fellows.  Their hopes had been burned to ashes.  Their scruples had been boiled to bone and tendon - or so it seemed.
out of calamity they had salvaged only the barest necessities; all else had been jettisoned.  Their spare manner, their guarded speech, their disinterested contempt for excess, all spoke to a dangerous thrift.  And nowhere was this more evident than in their eyes; they stared with the blank wariness of men who never slept - not peering, not watching, but observing, and with a directness that transcended "bold" or "rude".
They stared as though nothing stared back, as though all were objects.
Among the newcomers, even the costumed caste-nobles seemed unable or unwilling to match their gaze.  Many tried to maintain appearances - the wry glances, the nods of acknowledgement - but their looks always returned to their boots or sandals.  To stand in the sight of such men, they somehow understood, was to be measured, not by something as flawed and as arbitrary as a man, but by the length and breadth of what they had suffered.
Their very look had become judgement, so much had they witnessed.

Enathpaneah has been abandoned.  They cross the country and enter Xerash.
Quote
By the Later Prophet's time, Xerash was an old and powerful kingdom, demanding and receiving tribute from both Amoteu and Enathpaneah.  The Amoti in particular thought the Xerashi an obscene race, a blight upon the land.  For the authors of The Tractate, it was a land of innumerable brothels, fratricidal kings, and rampant homosexuality.  And though the blood and custom of the Nilnameshi had been thinned into extinction long ago, for the Men of the Tusk "xeratic" still meant "sodomite", and they punished the Fanim of Xerash for the trespasses of others long dead.  The Xerashi that the Inrithi wandered through was a place of old and labyrinthine evils.  And her people found themselves called to account not once, but twice.

There are massacres, including of refugees, until Kellhus takes action and punished the worst perpetrators.  But the result is that
Quote
...all Xerash was closed to them

the journey to Xerash reminds Akka of his days tutoring Proyas.  The deference he receives as the Holy Tutor, and the fact that he rides and not walks.  He has found himself
Quote
...awash in small riches.
Quote
...The live of a spy was hard.  To finally have things, even things he couldn't bring himself to enjoy, eased his heart for some reason, as though they were balm for unseen wounds...

There is no politicking among the Sacral Retinue.
Quote
...All knives were sheathed in the Warrior-Prophet's hallowed presence.

He enjoys the camaraderie of the Nascenti, and joins in with their hymns.
Quote
...Then he would glimpse Esmenet rocking in her saddle amid her servants, or he would see another corpse mute in the surrounding grasses, and he would recall the purpose of their journey.
They rode to war - to kill.  To conquer Holy Shimeh.
In these moments, the differences between his present circumstance and his time as Proyas' tutor would loom stark before him, and the fleecy sense of reminiscence that seemed to permeate everything would grow hard with cold and dread.  What was it he remembered?

A tribe of local Inrithi, the Surdu, come to the Holy War, to guide them through the Betmulla mountains.  Kellhus knows that Fanayal has sent them - he has abducted their families.  The Surdu are flayed alive in public.
Quote
The image of the chieftain kneeling with the bent sword nagged Achamian for the remainder of the day.  Once again he was certain he'd witnessed something remarkably similar - but not in Conriya.  It couldn't be... The sword he remembered had been bronze.

His memories of Conriya, are in fact Seswatha's memories of Kuniuri.

Quote
It always jarred Achamin, realising that so much of what he was he in fact wasn't.  Now he found himself terrified by the contrary realisation: that more and more he was becoming what he wasn't - what he must never be.  That he was becoming Seswatha.
For so long the sheer scale of the Dreams had offered him an immunity of sorts.  The things he dreamed simply didn't happen - at least not to the likes of him.  With the Holy War, his life had taken a turn to the legendary, and the distance between his world and Seswatha's closed, at least in terms of what he witnessed.  But even than, what he lived remained banal and impoverished.  "Seswatha never shat". the old Mandate joke went.  The dimensions of what Achamian lived could always fall into the dimensions of what he dreamed like a stone into a potter's urn.
But now, riding as Holy Tutor at the Warrior-Prophet's left hand?
In a way, he was as much as Seswatha, if not more.  In a way, he no longer shat either.  And knowing this was enough to make him shit.
Strangely enough, the Dreams themselves had become more bearable.  Tywanrae and Dagliash continued to predominate, though as always he couldn't fathom why they should follow this or any other rhythm of events.  They were like swallows, swooping and circling in aimless patterns, sketching something almost, yet never quite, a language...
...Through Kellhus, the scale of the present not only matched the scale of his Dreams, it counterbalanced them with hope...
...Augury, Memgowa had written, said more about men's fear than about their future.  But how could Achamian resist?  ...There would be glory this time.  Victory would not come at the cost of all that mattered.
Min-Uroikas broken.  Shauriatas, Mekeritrig, Aurang and Aurax - all of them destroyed!  The No-God unresurrected.  The Consult a memory stamped into the muck.
Despite their opiate glamour, there was something terrifying about these thoughts.  The Gods were perverse.  Natter as they might, the priests knew nothing of their malicious whims.  Perhaps thy would see the world burn just to punish the hubris of one man.  Nothing, Achamian had long ago decided, was quite so dangerous as boredom in the absence of scruples.

His discourse with Kellhus merely feeds his apprehension.  Why go to Shimeh, when the enemy is in Golgotterath?  Akka is unique.  He never asks Kellhus after his soul
Quote
"With me," Kellhus continued, "the Tusk is rewritten, Akka."  A long, ransacking look.  "Do you understand?  Or do you simply prefer to think yourself damned?"
Though he could muster no retort, Achamian knew.
He preferred.

He contacts Nautzera. Whilst the other man formally has the power of life and  death over Akka, Akka realises that because he is the only one with a connection to Kellhus, that he is the defacto Grandmaster of the Mandate.
He relays a message from Kellhus to the Quorum
Quote
..."You are players in this war, nothing more.  The balance remains precarious.  Recall what it is you dream.  Recall the ancient errors.  Do not act out of conceit or ignorance"...
What?  Does he imply that he possesses this war?  Who is he compared with what we know, what we dream?...
"He, Nautzera, is the Warrior-Prophet".

65
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 3
« on: January 17, 2019, 09:08:51 pm »
Quote
Unlike the Inrithi, he [Cnaiur] did not stand within the circle of the Dunyain's deceit.  Where they saw things from within, he saw them from without.  He saw more.  It was strange the way beliefs could have an inside and an outside, that what looked like hope or truth or love from within could be scythe or a hammer, things wielded for other ends, when seen from without.
Tools.

Quote
The Inrithi, Proyas had told him once, believed it was the lot of men to live within the designs, inscrutable or otherwise, of those greater than themselves.  And in this sense, Cnaiur realised, Kellhus truly was their prophet.  They were, as the memorialists claimed, willing slaves, always striving to beat down the furies that drove them to sovereign ends.  That the designs - the tracks - they claimed to follow were authored in the Outside simply served their vanity, allowed them to abase themselves in a manner that fanned their overweening pride.  There was no greater tyranny, the memorialists said, than that exercised by slaves over slaves.
But now the slaver stood among them.  What did it matter, Kellhus had asked as they crossed the Steppe, that he mastered those already enslaved?  There was no honour, only advantage.  To believe in honour was to stand inside things, to keep company with slaves and fools.

This tells us how the Gods 'work'. 

If Cnaiur is 'outside', then is he somehow more than other men, divine, a god?  If Kellhus seems to be 'inside' and 'outside' at the same time, what is he? 
They are both
(click to show/hide)
, is this foreshadowing?

66
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 3
« on: January 17, 2019, 09:03:38 pm »
Conphas tells them that the whole thing is a fraud.
Kellhus puts him in his place
Quote
"... you don't know whether to offer the same pretence of submission that you offer your uncle or to discredit me with open words.  So now you deny me out of desperation, not to to prove to others that I'm a fraud but to prove yourself that you are in fact my better.  For an obscene arrogance dwells within you, Ikurei Conphas, the belief that you are the measure of all other men.  It is this lie that you seek to preserve at all costs...

...To preserve your pride before me, you must endure the shame of lying.  You must conceal who you are, in order to prove who you are.  You must degrade yourself to remain proud.  At this moment you see this more clearly than at other time in your life, and yet still you refuse to relinquish, to yield to your tormented pride.  You trade the anguish that breeds anguish for the anguish that breeds release.  You would rather take pride in what you are not than take pride in what you are...

...Shame is a stranger to you, Ikurei Conphas.  An unbearable stranger"

Conphas speaks his contempt for the others and leaves.  Kellhus commands him to halt.

Quote
"... Pride is a sickness... For most it's a fever, a contagion goaded by the glories of others.  But for some, like you Ikurei Conphas, it is a defect carried from the womb.  For your whole life you've wondered what it was that moved the men about you.  Why would a father sell himself into slavery, when he need only strangle his children?  Why would a young man take the Orders of the Tusk, exchange the luxuries of his station for a cubicle, authority for servitude to the Holy Shriah?  Why do so many give, when it is so easy to take?
But you ask these questions because you know nothing of strength.  For what is strength but the resolve to deny base inclinations - the determination to sacrifice in the name of one's brothers?  You, Ikurei Conphas, know only weakness, and because it takes strength to acknowledge weakness, you call your weakness strength.  You betray your brother.  You fresco your heart with flatteries.  You, who are less than any man, say to yourself, 'I am a god'"

Shades of Gandalf and Saruman after the fall of Isengard.

67
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 3
« on: January 17, 2019, 09:00:34 pm »
Iyokus is in a grove surrounded by Chorae bowmen.  There are great stone dolmens there.
Quote
...Such remnants, he thought, were the metric of ages, the pilings of the present. They spoke of a time when no Caraskand had encompassed these hills, a time when his own ancestors had ranged the endless plains beyond the Great Kayarsus.  To lay eyes on such monuments, he knew, to truly see them, was to understand the terrifying of dimensions of what had been forgotten.

Did the Nonmen erect the dolmens? or the Emwama?

68
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 3
« on: January 16, 2019, 09:09:27 pm »
Quote
... when the hot winds chased the clouds to oblivion, they simply followed the forage, always searching for the wild herbs and short grasses that made for the best meat and milk.
This pursuit always caught someone, particularly those who were too greedy to cull wilful animals from their herd.  Headstrong cattle could lead an entire herd too far afield, into vast tracks of over-grazed or blighted pasture.  Every season, it seemed, some fool returned without horse of cattle.
Cnaiur now knew himself to be that fool.
I have given him the Holy War

Various notables are in the council chamber in Caraskand, including Akka
Quote
The sorceror, that woman-hearted buffoon whom everyone thought dead...
, and the Great Names
Quote
... now little more than counsellors, and they knew it...
For the first time in their lives they stood upon trackless ground...

Quote
...What would they do, the devout and self-righteous alike?  What would they do now that their hallowed scripture could talk back?

Kellhus has
Quote
... given them dominion.  Over their doubts.  Over their most hated foes. He had made them strong.
But how could lies do such a thing?

Quote
Unlike the Inrithi, he [Cnaiur] did not stand within the circle of the Dunyain's deceit.  Where they saw things from within, he saw them from without.  He saw more.  It was strange the way beliefs could have an inside and an outside, that what looked like hope or truth or love from within could be scythe or a hammer, things wielded for other ends, when seen from without.
Tools.

Quote
The Inrithi, Proyas had told him once, believed it was the lot of men to live within the designs, inscrutable or otherwise, of those greater than themselves.  And in this sense, Cnaiur realised, Kellhus truly was their prophet.  They were, as the memorialists claimed, willing slaves, always striving to beat down the furies that drove them to sovereign ends.  That the designs - the tracks - they claimed to follow were authored in the Outside simply served their vanity, allowed them to abase themselves in a manner that fanned their overweening pride.  There was no greater tyranny, the memorialists said, than that exercised by slaves over slaves.
But now the slaver stood among them.  What did it matter, Kellhus had asked as they crossed the Steppe, that he mastered those already enslaved?  There was no honour, only advantage.  To believe in honour was to stand inside things, to keep company with slaves and fools.

Saubon will not march to Shimeh.  Caraskand is his.

Conphas tells them that the whole thing is a fraud.
Kellhus puts him in his place
Quote
"... you don't know whether to offer the same pretence of submission that you offer your uncle or to discredit me with open words.  So now you deny me out of desperation, not to to prove to others that I'm a fraud but to prove yourself that you are in fact my better.  For an obscene arrogance dwells within you, Ikurei Conphas, the belief that you are the measure of all other men.  It is this lie that you seek to preserve at all costs...

...To preserve your pride before me, you must endure the shame of lying.  You must conceal who you are, in order to prove who you are.  You must degrade yourself to remain proud.  At this moment you see this more clearly than at other time in your life, and yet still you refuse to relinquish, to yield to your tormented pride.  You trade the anguish that breeds anguish for the anguish that breeds release.  You would rather take pride in what you are not than take pride in what you are...

...Shame is a stranger to you, Ikurei Conphas.  An unbearable stranger"

Conphas speaks his contempt for the others and leaves.  Kellhus commands him to halt.

Quote
"... Pride is a sickness... For most it's a fever, a contagion goaded by the glories of others.  But for some, like you Ikurei Conphas, it is a defect carried from the womb.  For your whole life you've wondered what it was that moved the men about you.  Why would a father sell himself into slavery, when he need only strangle his children?  Why would a young man take the Orders of the Tusk, exchange the luxuries of his station for a cubicle, authority for servitude to the Holy Shriah?  Why do so many give, when it is so easy to take?
But you ask these questions because you know nothing of strength.  For what is strength but the resolve to deny base inclinations - the determination to sacrifice in the name of one's brothers?  You, Ikurei Conphas, know only weakness, and because it takes strength to acknowledge weakness, you call your weakness strength.  You betray your brother.  You fresco your heart with flatteries.  You, who are less than any man, say to yourself, 'I am a god'"

Cnaiur is for a moment 'inside'

The Nansur are to disarm and march to Joktha to take ship home.  Kellhus knows they have conspired with the Fanim.

Quote
The Dunyain simply culled the wilful from his herd

Proyas is thinking on what has come to pass
Quote
What had he been thinking?  How could he, a man who had meticulously hammered his heart into the very shape of piety, have come so close to murdering the God's own voice?
The thought still dizzied him, struck him nauseous with shame.
Conviction, no matter how narcotic its depth, simply did not make true.  This was a hard lesson, made all harder by its astounding conspicuousness.  Despite the exhortations of kings and generals, despite the endless lays, belief unto death was cheap.  After all, the Fanim threw themselves against the spears of their enemies as readily as the Inrithi.  Someone had to be deluded.  So what ensured that that someone was someone else?  Given the manifest frailty of men, given the long succession of delusions that their history, what could be more preposterous than claiming oneself the least deluded, let alone privy to the absolute?
And to make such obvious conceit the grounds condemnation... of murder...
In all his life, Proyas had never wept so hard as he had at the Warrior-Prophet's feet.  For he, who had decried avarice in all its forms, had proven the most avaricious of all.  He had coveted nothing so much as the truth, and since truth had so roundly eluded him, he had turned to his beliefs.  How could he not when he'd spent a lifetime abasing himself before them, when they afforded him such a luxury of judgement?
When they were so much who he was.
The promise of rebirth was at once the threat of murder, and Proyas, like so many others, had opted to kill rather than die.

Proyas can see halos around Kellhus' fingers.

Cnaiur knows Proyas has been set by Kellhus.  Cnaiur is to remain in Joktha - to kill Conphas.  Culled from the herd.

Iyokus is in a grove surrounded by Chorae bowmen.  There are great stone dolmens there.
Quote
...Such remnants, he thought, were the metric of ages, the pilings of the present. They spoke of a time when no Caraskand had encompassed these hills, a time when his own ancestors had ranged the endless plains beyond the Great Kayarsus.  To lay eyes on such monuments, he knew, to truly see them, was to understand the terrifying of dimensions of what had been forgotten.

Another sorceror approaches.  Achamian.  Kellhus is not there.
Quote
"You were deceived," the Mandate Schoolman said...
..."He's given you to me, Iyokus.  The Warrior-Prophet.  I asked for vengeance.  I begged.

They fight.  Sorcerous combat.  The Gnosis is the stronger.

Cnaiur rides out into the hills.
Quote
He was no longer of the People.  He was more.  There was no thought he could not think.  No act he could undertake.  No lips he could not kiss...  Nothing was forbidden.

He dreams of Serwe, and then she is there.  He catches her in a clearing.  Her face flies apart - a skin-spy.  The Synthese arrives.
Quote
"Old," the tiny face said in a reedy voice.  "Old is the covenant between our peoples."
Cnaiur stared in horror.  "I belong to no people," he said blankly.
A vertiginous silence.  It peered at him with an avian canniness, as though forced to revisit certain long standing assumptios.
"Perhaps," it said.  "But something binds you to him.  You would not have saved him otherwise.  You would not have killed my child"
Cnaiur spat.  "Nothing binds me"
It craned its tiny face to the side, bird-curious.
"But the past binds us all, Scylvendi, as the bow binds the flight of an arrow.  All of us have been nocked, raised and released.  All that remains is to see where we land... to see whether we strike true."

It knows about Moenghus - how?

Cnaiur thinks his hunt is over.  But the Synthese tells him he has been moved, nothing more.

Akka comes to Ximenus, who is very drunk.  He gives him Iyokus' eyes. Xin puts them into his own sockets.  He still cannot see.
Poor Xinemus.  Both tragic and pitiful.

Blinded, Iyokus comes back to Eleazaras.
Quote
"The words," Eleazaras hissed.  "Do you remember the words?"
In sorcery, everything depended on the purity of meaning.  Who knew what blinding might do?
"Y-yessss."
"Then you are whole"

69
The Almanac: PON Edition / ARC: TTT Chapter 4
« on: January 13, 2019, 06:55:59 pm »
Quote
Like a stern father, war shames men into hating their childhood games
- PROTATHIS, ONE HUNDRED HEAVENS

Quote
I returned from that campaign  far different man, or so my mother continuously complained.  "Now only the dead," she would tell me, "can hope to match your gaze".
- TRIAMIS I, JOURNALS AND DISCOURSES

70
The Almanac: PON Edition / ARC: TTT Chapter 3
« on: January 13, 2019, 06:53:49 pm »
Quote
If soot stains your tunic, dye it black.  This is vengeance.
- EKYANNUS I, 44 EPISTLES

Quote
Here we find further argument for Gotagga's supposition that the world is round.  How else could all men stand higher than their brothers?
- AJENCUS, DISCOURSE ON WAR

71
Quote
All men surrender, Akka, even as they seek to dominate.  It's their nature to submit.  The question is never whether they will surrender, but rather to whom..."
The Men of the Tusk submit to the God - it preserves their pride.  There is no fear of degradation.  Others, like Achamian, submit to other people.  Lovers injure, humiliate and debase, but never test, not if they truly love.  Esmenet is not testing Achamian.  Neither Kellhus nor Esmi can undo Achamian's suffering - it is his own.  The skin-spy (which is ranting, thrashing and howling throughout) is his test, because he is a Mandate Schoolman.

Is Kellhus admitting he cannot break Akka's Mandate conditioning - i.e. the link with Seswatha (which we have seen in action during Akka's torture in TWP)?

72
The Almanac: PON Edition / Re: ARC: TTT Chapter 2
« on: January 13, 2019, 03:44:24 pm »
Cnaiur goes looking for his son
Quote
Why, Cnaiur wondered, would the Dunyain keep this child?  What did he see when he looked upon it?  What use was there in a child?
There was no interval between the world and an infant soul.  No deception.  No language.  A infant's wail simply was its hunger. And it occurred to Cnaiur that if he abandoned this child, it would become an Inrithi, but if he took it, stole away and rode hard for the Steppe, it would become a Scylvendi.  And his hair prickled across his scalp, for there was magic in that - even doom.
This wail would not always be one with the child's hunger.  The interval would lengthen, and the tracks between its soul and its expression would multiply, become more and more unfathomable. This singular need would be unbraided into a thousand strands of lust and hope, bound into a thousand knots and fear and shame.  And it would wince beneath the upraised hand of a father, sigh at the soft touch of the mother.  It would become what circumstance demanded.  Inrithi or Scylvendi...
It did not matter.
And suddenly, improbably, Cnaiur understood what it was the Dunyain saw: a world of infant men, their wails beaten into words, into tongues, into nations.  Kellhus could see the measure of the interval, he could close the interval, answer the wail... Make souls one with their expression.
As his father had before him.  Moenghus.

He raises a fist to strike, but Esmenet stops him.  He ends up on his knees before the crib.
Interesting because, at the end of TUC, it is not clear where Moenghus' loyalties lie.

Xinemus has become a drunk.  He begs Achamian to talk to Kellhus for him.

Esmi is dressed by her slaves
Quote
It was with awe that Esmenet greeted her own image in the mirror, an awe she saw reflected in the admiring eyes of her body slaves.  She was beautiful - as beautiful as Serwe, only dark.  Staring at the exotic stranger before her, she could almost believe she was worth what so many had made of her.  She could almost believe that all this was real.

She meets Werjau.  Men have been caught painting Orthodox slogans.  It is assumed they were paid by Conphas.
Quote
"... Have them flayed and posted".
The ease with which these words fell from her lips was nothing short of nightmarish.  One breath and these men, these piteous fools, would die in torment.  A breath that could have been used for anything: a moan of pleasure, a gasp, a word of mercy...
This she understood, was power: the translation of word into fact.  She need only speak and the world would be rewritten.  Before, her voice could conjure only custom, ragged breaths, and quickened seed.  before, her cries could only forestall affliction and wheedle what small mercies might come.  But now her voice had become that mercy, that affliction.
Such thoughts made her head swim.

Quote
... Kellhus had warned her about Werjau.  The man resented her, he said, both because she was a woman and because of his native pride...

Many skin-spies seem to have slipped the net.

She attends the Penance, where the Nascenti lash believers - including Proyas.

Akka has been installed in the library.  She goes in to get a book, and tells him Kellhus has taught her to read.
Quote
"I..." he began.  "I was your life... I know I was, Esmi."...
... What does he matter?  His heart was broken long before -
"Yes," she repeated, "you were my life".  When she raised her face, it was with weariness, not the ferocity she had expected. "And he is my world."

She is with Kellhus later.
Quote
"He will not forgive," she whispered.
There was indecision in his look, frightening for its rarity.  "He will not forgive".
Is Kellhus' indecision genuine?

Iyokus has arrived in Caraskand, to find Eleazaras has turned to drink.
Quote
"Believe it.  The Consult exists.  All this time,laughing at the Mandati, and it was we who were the mumming fools".
A long accusatory silence.  Iyokus had always told him he should heed their claims more seriously...

Eleazaras believe Kellhus is a prophet.  He sees
Quote
"... the secrets you keep from yourself"... "He sees what breaks your heart"
You have doomed your School
"You're drunk," the chanv addict said, his tone both unnerved and disgusted.

Eli tells Iyokus to beware the Mandate Schoolman.

73
For Achamian the past no longer defines the future.  He contacts the Mandate - a beetle passes by as he speaks the spell. - Ajokli reference?

He finds Nautzera pinned to wall of corpses at Dagliash. A Bashrag nails a living man to the wall.  Together with the last scenes of TWP, we are shown how horrific the Consult are.

Mekeritrig appears. He tells Nautzera/ Seswatha that all monuments or memorials are obscenities.

Quote
A cut scarred where a caress faded away.  In this simple fact lay the tragic and catastrophic truth of the Nonmen.  Mekeritirg had lived a hundred lifetimes - more!  What would it be like, Achamian wondered, to have every redeeming memory - be it a lover's touch or a child's warm squeal - blotted out by the accumulation of anguish, terror, and hate? To understand the soul of a Nonman, the philosopher Gotagga had once written, one need only bare the back of an old and arrogant slave. Scars.  Scars upon scars.  This was what made them mad.  All of them.
"I am an Erratic," Mekeritrig was saying.  "I do that which I hate, I raise my heart to the lash, so that I might remember!  Do you understand what this means?  You are my children!"

He wants the Heron Spear and thinks Seswatha knows where it is.
Quote
"I will strip you to your footings," the Nonman grated.  "Though I love, I will upend your soul's foundation! I will release you from the delusions of this word 'Man', and draw forth the beast - the soulless beast! - that is the howling Truth of all things... You will tell me!"
The old man coughed, drooled blood.
"And I, Seswatha... I will remember!"

Quote
... With volcanic palms, Mekeritrig clenched Seswatha's brow, serrated both body and soul.
Nautzera howled in voices not his own.
"Shhhh," Mekeritrig whispered, clutching the old sorceror's cheek.  He squeezed away tears with his thumb.  "Hush, child..."
Nautzera could only gag and convulse.
"Please," the Nonman said.  "Please do not cry..."

Akka manages to break the dream an speak to his colleague.  He tells him about Kellhus.  Nautzera tells him to do everything in his power to protect Kellhus.  Akka tells Nautzera that Kellhus wants the Gnosis.  Nautzera asks if Akka can be trusted - like Akka trusted Nautzera regarding Inrau.  Akka is to teach him the lesser cants.

Quote
You still don't understand, do you, Nautzera?  The Warrior-Prophet cannot be deceived!
All men can be deceived, Achamian. All men.
- Harks back to the first prologue in TDTCB, and forward to the ending of TUC.

The Men of the Tusk are victorious.  They eat Fanim food and drink Fanim drink.  Captives are told to curse Fane - those who do are sold to slavers.  Those who don't are killed, and Kellhus anoints the Inrithi with their blood.  We are again reminded that the Holy War and Kellhus are not the 'good guys'

Akka goes to the Fama Palace.  He realises that Kellhus would change the world, in the way of an Inri Sejenus.  It is year 1 of a new age.
Quote
The eyes of men were but pinholes - no one knew this better than Mandate Schoolmen.  All their books, even their scriptures, were nothing more than pinholes.  And yet, because they couldn't see what was unseen, they assumed they saw everything, they confused pinpricks with the sky.
But Kellhus was something different.  A doorway.  A mighty gate.
He's come to save us.  This is what I must remember. I must hold on to this.

Esmi is there, walking with Kellhus.
Quote
She was Esmenet and yet she wasn't Esmenet.  The woman of loose life had fallen away, and what remained was more, so much more, than she'd been at his side.  Resplendent.
Redeemed.
I dimmed her, he realised.  I was smoke and he... is a mirror.

Kellhus tells him never to kneel in his presence.  He knows Akka has contacted the Mandate.  Akka will give him the Gnosis. Akka is to be Kellhus' Vizier.

A skin-spy is strung up to a tree.  They are powerfully conditioned - it would take Kellhus months to break them.
Quote
Achamian nodded.  Given time, he realised, Kellhus could empty this creature, own it as he seemed to own everything else.  He was more than thorough, more than meticulous.  Even the swiftness of this discovery - wrested, no less, from a creature that had been forged to deceive - demonstrated his... inevitability.
He makes no mistakes
For a giddy instant a kind of gloating fury descended upon Achamian.  All those years - centuries! - the Consult had played them for fools.  But now - now!  Did they know?  Could they sense the peril this man represented?  Or would they underestimate him like everyone else had?
Like Esmenet.
Kellhus does of course make mistakes - as we find out in TAE.  But note the faith Akka, Esmi and others have placed in him.

Quote
All men surrender, Akka, even as they seek to dominate.  It's their nature to submit.  The question is never whether they will surrender, but rather to whom..."
The Men of the Tusk submit to the God - it preserves their pride.  There is no fear of degradation.  Others, like Achamian, submit to other people.  Lovers injure, humiliate and debase, but never test, not if they truly love.  Esmenet is not testing Achamian.  Neither Kellhus nor Esmi can undo Achamian's suffering - it is his own.  The skin-spy (which is ranting, thrashing and howling throughout) is his test, because he is a Mandate Schoolman.

74
From what has come before - the Kellhus section, we learn that Esmenet has an
Quote
extraordinary native intelligence
  Any sons Kellhus has with her will be powerful tools - interesting that it doesn't say children - daughters dismissed.

75
The Almanac: PON Edition / ARC: TTT Chapter 2
« on: January 06, 2019, 07:02:30 pm »
Quote
I tell you, guilt dwells nowhere but in the eyes of the accuser.  This men know even as they deny it, which is why they so often make murder their absolution.  The truth of crime lies not with victim, but with the witness.
- HATATIAN - EXHORTATIONS

Pages: 1 ... 3 4 [5] 6 7 ... 19