As per categories, I don't like Neuter and Materialistic.
Pictures per category?
I like Enjoy's layout but that just makes me a minimalist, I think; I don't know about my aesthetic commitments.
I like Dark Dream Yellow but I am extremely hesitant regarding light on dark (perhaps - hopefully - what I like are the fonts and layout).
StickUp or Bright are the better two examples of that sidebar recent posts - don't like those at all for that reason.
I do like the scrolling banners on Darkly.
Ultimately, though, I don't really care what's picked so long as its sourced on the suggestions of the members - if it was unanimous, I'd probably go light on dark.